keto-enol tautomerization

Problem # 744

After a sample of optically pure (S)-2-ethyl-cyclohexanone is dissolved in an aqueous solution for several hours, a significant loss of optical activity is observed. Explain.

Solution

Carbonyls are in equilibrium with their enol forms. This process is called keto-enol tautomerization. (See problems 738 and 739). So when this compound is placed in water a small amount of it will constantly be converted to its enol form, and then back again to the carbonyl form.

But the enol form is achiral! (the alpha carbon is sp² instead of sp³as in the carbonyl form).

So when the achiral enol goes back to its carbonyl form, half will become (S) and the other half will become (R). The stereocenter becomes "scrambled." The process of an optically pure compound becoming a racemic mixture is called racemization.

Problem Details

MendelSet practice problem # 744 submitted by Matt on July 27, 2011.

Subject: Organic Chemistry

Subject Topic(s): Stereochemistry, Chirality, and Optical Activity, Carbonyl Alpha-Substitution Reactions (Enols and Enolates, Malonic Ester Syn, Stork)

Question Type: Concept (explain why this is so..)

Keyword(s): keto-enol tautomerization, racemization

Problem # 739

Carbonyls are in equilibrium with their enol forms. An enolate is the deprotonated form of an enol.

Enolates are formed from carbonyls under basic conditions.

Let's go through this equilibrium under basic conditions. Draw a mechanism using curved arrows for each reaction below.

Remember that under basic conditions, most species are either neutral or negatively charged, and rarely positively charged. So your structures will contain either ROH or RO^-, but not ROH₂⁺.

a) Carbonyl to Enolate (basic)

b) Enolate to Carbonyl (basic)

Solution

These mechanisms are similar to those in problem 738, only under basic conditions.

a) Carbonyl to Enolate (basic)

In the mechanism below the carbonyl was deprotonated at the alpha position, and the enolate was then drawn as a resonance form. You can also go straight from carbonyl to enolate in one reaction arrow. (rip off the proton, form the new double bond, and send the carbonyl "up" to form a negative charged oxygen).

b) Enolate to Carbonyl (basic) "DOWN"

Like a), this reaction can be done in one reaction arrow (negative charge comes "down" and double bond attacks a proton)

It's important that you become familiar with the mechanisms for enol and enolate formation in both acid (Q738) and in base (this problem), as well as carbonyl hydrate formation in both acid (Q706) and base (Q705).

If you can draw these four mechanisms you will be able to figure most of the reactions in second semester organic chemistry!

Problem Details

MendelSet practice problem # 739 submitted by Matt on July 27, 2011.

Subject: Organic Chemistry

Subject Topic(s): Carbonyl Alpha-Substitution Reactions (Enols and Enolates, Malonic Ester Syn, Stork)

Question Type: Mechanism (show a mechanism using curved arrows..)

Keyword(s): enols, enolates, keto-enol tautomerization

Problem # 738

Carbonyls are in equilibrium with their enol forms. This process is called keto-enol tautomerization.

This equilibrium happens in both acid and base.

Let's go through this equilibrium under acidic conditions. Draw a mechanism using curved arrows for each reaction below.

Remember that under acidic conditions, most species are either neutral or positively charged, and rarely negatively charged. So your structures will contain either ROH or ROH₂⁺, but not RO^-.

a) Carbonyl to Enol (acidic)

b) Enol to Carbonyl (acidic)

Solution

Enol and enolate mechanisms always involve the alpha position of the carbonyl (one away from the carbonyl carbon). This the alpha hydrogen is acidic, and so can be deprotonated.

To form an enol (or enolate) from a carbonyl, the alpha position of the carbonyl must be deprotonated, and the double bond (pi electrons) travels "goes up" to the oxygen to become a lone pair.

To form a carbonyl from an enol (or enolate), the alpha position of the carbonyl must be protonated, and a lone pair on the oxygen "comes down" to reform the carbonyl.

This "up and down" mechanism is similar to the Nucleophilic Acyl Addition/Substitution mechanisms discussed in problems 705 and 706, with the difference being that the carbon carbonyl is not where bond formation takes place. In enol/enolate mechanisms, new bond formation occurs at the alpha position.

a) Carbonyl to Enol (acidic) "UP"

Because this mechanism takes place under acidic conditions, the carbonyl oxygen must be protonated before its double bond "goes up" to form a lone pair.

b) Enol to Carbonyl (acidic) "DOWN"

Most people remember that a lone pair from the enol oxygen "comes down." But many forget that you have to add something back to the alpha position! In this case, it's just a hydrogen- you reprotonate the alpha position to form the carbonyl.