Lewis Structures, Formal Charges, and Resonance

Problem # 755

The nitrosyl cation is shown below. Also shown are several proposed resonance arrows, only one of which is correct.

Draw the resonance forms that would follow from each set of arrows, and include formal charges. Which one is the correct resonance form? Explain your reasoning.

Solution

When evaluating possible Lewis structures the most important rule to follow is the octet rule: every atom must be surrounded by 8 and only 8 electrons (atoms in period 3 or below on the periodic table have d orbitals and so can contain more than 8 electrons, but that exception does not apply here).

Do any of the resonance forms drawn have atoms that break the octet rule? Yes- they all do! Except for resonance arrows in D. So D is the correct resonance form.

Problem Details

MendelSet practice problem # 755 submitted by Matt on July 27, 2011.

Subject: Organic Chemistry

Subject Topic(s): Lewis Structures, Formal Charges, and Resonance, Diazonium Chemistry (NaNO2, Sandmeyer, Nitrosyl)

Question Type: Concept (explain why this is so..)

Keyword(s): resonance, Lewis structures

Problem # 580

Draw all resonance forms for each species.

For the anion and cation species, used curved arrows. For the radical species, use hooks.

Solution

(This is similar to problem 569, which involved the allylic position.)

Notice that arrows always go from high electron density to low electron density. So for negatively charged species, the arrow starts at the lone pair. For positively charged species, the arrow starts at the double bond and goes towards the positive charge.

(Radical resonance uses hooks instead of arrows and so is a little different.)