SN1/SN2/E1/E2 Trends and Competition Reactions

Problem # 703

Show two ways to prepare the ether below from a combination of an alcohol and an alkyl halide via the Williamson ether synthesis.

Is one way better than the other? Why?

Solution

The Williamson ether synthesis takes place in two steps. First an alcohol is deprotonated to form a strong nucleophile (RO^-, this step isn't shown in the image below). Then the alkoxide (negative alcohol) attacks an alkyl halide in an S_N2 reaction.

So this problem is really asking, which step of conditions is most favorable for an S_N2 reaction?

Recall that S_N2 reactions compete with E2 reactions. If the nucleophile is too basic, or if there is too much bulk, it will go E2 instead of S_N2. (See problem 560 for a full explanation of these competition reactions)

Below, the top combination uses the less substituted (1º) alkyl halide, and so is the best for an S_N2 reaction.

The bottom reaction uses a bulkier (2º) alkyl halide, and will probably give a higher percentage of E2 side reaction.

Problem Details

MendelSet practice problem # 703 submitted by Matt on July 21, 2011.

Subject: Organic Chemistry

Subject Topic(s): SN1/SN2/E1/E2 Trends and Competition Reactions, Ethers and Epoxides

Question Type: Concept (explain why this is so..)

Keyword(s): SN1/SN2/E1/E2, Williamson ether synthesis

Problem # 560

For each reaction below, determine whether the primary reaction is S_N1, S_N2, E1, or E2, and then draw the product.

Note: Me = methyl (CH₃)

Solution

Predicting S_N1/S_N2/E1/E2 competition reactions tends to drive students crazy, but it's not so bad once you notice the general pattern:

basic conditions (positive and negative charges) tend to go S_N2 or E2 (no carbocation)
neutral or acidic conditions tend to go S_N1 or E1 (carbocation is formed).

That's how you determine a SN1/E1 reaction from an SN2/E2 reaction. But how to decide between substitution or elimination? General things to watch for are bulk, nucleophilicity, and heat:

If you see heat (or Δ), the reaction will go elimination.
If you see a big, bulky compound, the reaction will go elmination.
If you see a strong base, the reaction will go elimination. Strong base is anything stronger than RO^-.

The exception: if everything is primary, it will probably go S_N2.

These rules probably seem confusing, so let's go through these eight examples and see how they apply.

a) NaCN is charged! (Na⁺ and CN^-), so it's S_N2 or E2. CN is not a strong base, so it's S_N2.

b) KOtBu (potassium tert-butoxide) is charged, so it's S_N2 or E2. ^-OtBu is a strong base, so if anything is more bulky than 1º it will go E2. ^-OtBu is 3º, so it will definitely go E2 (KOtBu is a classic E2 reagent).

c) NaOMe is charged so E2 or S_N2. NaOMe is a strong base, so if anything >1º it will go E2. ^-OMe is 1º (actually, not even 1º), but the alkyl halide is 2º, so it will go E2.

d) NaOMe is charged so E2 or S_N2. NaOMe is a strong base, so if anything >1º it will go E2. But in this case there is no bulk whatsoever- nothing is >1º! NaOMe is 1 and the alkyl halide is also 1º, so it will go S_N2.

e) Methanol (MeOH) is neutral so probably E1 or S_N1. Methanol is a weak base and there's no bulk, so S_N1. In general water and alcohol do a mixture of S_N1 and E1 with alkyl halides (mostly S_N1).

f) H₂SO₄ is acidic so probably E1 or S_N1. Can't be S_N1 though because there is no nucleophile in H₂SO₄. (HSO₄^- is a very weak nucleophile). An alcohol with H₂SO₄ or H₃PO₄ is a dehydration reaction- E1.

g) H₂SO₄ is acidic so probably E1 or S_N1. In this case we have a nucleophile- Cl^-, so it will go S_N1.

h) Amines are neutral but they don't so S_N1/E1- they tend to go S_N2/E2, because they are basic (an amine solution has a basic pH). This amine is really bulky so it will go E2.