EDG and EWG

MS 913 - Benzene EAS Reactions, EDG/EWG, and ortho/meta/para Directors Submitted by Matt on August 6, 2011.

Textbook and Chapter: Carey and Giuliano 8th Ed. (2010), Chapter 12

Keywords: EAS mechanism, EDG and EWG, Friedel-Crafts

Description: Covers electrophilic aromatic substitution (EAS) reactions in detail.

It includes many, many resonance exercises that show why:

  • Electron donating groups (EDG) are ortho-para directors
  • Electron withdrawing groups (EWG) are meta-directors
  • Pyrrole undergoes EAS at C-2 and not C-3
  • Pyridine undergoes EAS at C-3 and not C-2 or C-4
  • Naphthalene undergoes EAS at C-1 and not C-2

Total Problems: 11

Problem # 753

Rank the amines W through Z below in order of decreasing basicity (1 = most basic). Explain your reasoning.

Problem # 752

Rank the amines A through D below in order of decreasing basicity (1 = most basic). Explain your reasoning.

Problem # 748

Alpha bromination is usually carried out under acidic conditions via the enol intermediate. 

Alpha bromination is uncontrollable under basic conditions, which goes through the enolate intermediate. Let's explore why.

     

 

a) Rank each carbonyl below in order of decreasing alpha-proton acidity (1= most acidic). Explain.

b) based on a), why does the reaction below lead to polyhalogenation?

Problem # 710
 

Rank the carbonyls A-D below in order of decreasing electrophilicity (reactivity with nucleophiles).

(1 = Most reactive).  Explain your reasoning.

Problem # 588

Let's draw resonance forms to see why some groups are EDG or EWG. (I've started you off)

Where are the positive or negative charges placed in EDG/EWG? (ortho/meta/para) Why would this affect EAS reactions?

Note: EDG = electron donating group, EWG = electron withdrawing group