Textbook: Wade 7th Ed. (2009)

Chapter 17: Reactions of Aromatic Compounds

Practice Problems (No matching mendel sets were found.)

Short link: mendelset.com/chapters/1035

Printer-friendly version

Individual Problems

Individual Problems

Problem # 588

Let's draw resonance forms to see why some groups are EDG or EWG. (I've started you off)

Where are the positive or negative charges placed in EDG/EWG? (ortho/meta/para) Why would this affect EAS reactions?

Note: EDG = electron donating group, EWG = electron withdrawing group

Solution

The resonance forms for EDG add electron density to the ring (and add a negative charge), while the resonance forms for EWG remove electron density from the ring (and leave a positive charge). This is where the terms electron donating group and electron withdrawing group come from.

EAS reactions require benzene to attack something positive (an electrophile), so the more electron density, the better. This is why EDG tend to speed up EAS reactions, while EWG slow down EAS reactions.

Notice that for EDG, the ortho and para positions are partially negative. In EAS reactions benzene attacks a positively charged electrophile, so its not too surprising that the electrophile will want to add at o/p if a EDG is present.

But for EWG, the o/p positions pick up a partial positive charge. So for EAS reactions with a EWG, it's not surprising that the electrophile will avoid the o/p positions, and add meta instead.

This is one explanation for the general trend:

EDG are ortho/para directors and activating.
EWG are meta directors and deactivating.

Problem Details

MendelSet practice problem # 588 submitted by Matt on July 9, 2011.

Subject: Organic Chemistry

Subject Topic(s): Substituted Benzene EAS (EDG and EWG Effects)

Question Type: Concept (explain why this is so..)

Keyword(s): EAS mechanism, EDG and EWG

Problem # 587

Use curved arrows to draw a mechanism for the generic electrophilic aromatic substitution (EAS) reaction below.

Solution

Notice that the electrophile takes the place of the hydrogen.

Problem Details

MendelSet practice problem # 587 submitted by Matt on July 9, 2011.

Subject: Organic Chemistry

Subject Topic(s): Electrophilic Aromatic Substitution

Question Type: Mechanism (show a mechanism using curved arrows..)

Keyword(s): EAS mechanism

Problem # 596

Indicate the eletrophile formed by each set of reagents/conditions below.

Solution

Note that some textbooks don't draw EAS electrophiles with formal positive charges.

Some textbooks instead draw electrophiles with partial positive charges and a leaving group. It's just a convention, and doesn't affect the product of an EAS reaction. See the problem 595 for an explanation of the difference.

Problem Details

MendelSet practice problem # 596 submitted by Matt on July 9, 2011.

Subject: Organic Chemistry

Subject Topic(s): Electrophilic Aromatic Substitution

Question Type: Concept (explain why this is so..)

Keyword(s): EAS mechanism

Problem # 678

Draw the structure of the major organic product from each reaction sequence.

Solution

The purpose of this problem is to illustrate that there are often several routes to prepare a single molecule.

For the left route:

Br₂/FeBr₃ adds a bromine to benzene via EAS.
Mg/ether converts bromobenzene to phenyl Grignard (a nucleophile).
Phenyl Grignard attacks the aldehyde.
A protic workup gets rid of all negative charges (and quenches the Grignard reagent).

For the right route:

Benzene undergoes Friedel-Crafts acylation (an EAS reaction) to form the ketone.
The ketone is then reduced to an alcohol using NaBH₄.

Note that both methods add a carbon chain to benzene, a step that is quite common in synthesis problems!

Problem Details

MendelSet practice problem # 678 submitted by Matt on July 19, 2011.

Subject: Organic Chemistry

Subject Topic(s): Electrophilic Aromatic Substitution, Alcohol Oxidation Reactions (PCC, Jones Reagent)

Question Type: Reactions (predict the product, show the starting material..)

Keyword(s): hydride reduction

Problem # 580

Draw all resonance forms for each species.

For the anion and cation species, used curved arrows. For the radical species, use hooks.

Solution

(This is similar to problem 569, which involved the allylic position.)

Notice that arrows always go from high electron density to low electron density. So for negatively charged species, the arrow starts at the lone pair. For positively charged species, the arrow starts at the double bond and goes towards the positive charge.

(Radical resonance uses hooks instead of arrows and so is a little different.)

Problem Details

MendelSet practice problem # 580 submitted by Matt on July 9, 2011.

Subject: Organic Chemistry

Subject Topic(s): Lewis Structures, Formal Charges, and Resonance, Benzene Side Chain Reactions and the Benzylic Position

Question Type: Concept (explain why this is so..)

Keyword(s): resonance, benzylic position

Problem # 589

-OR is an EDG and an ortho-para director. Let's draw an EAS reaction's cyclohexadienyl cation intermediates to demonstrate why this is true. I've started you off.

What's good about ortho/para? What's bad about meta?

Solution

Short answer: -OR is an ortho/para director because the cyclohexadienyl intermediates that result from ortho and para addtitions are more stable than those that result from meta addition.

Long answer: The cyclohexadienyl intermediates from ortho and para addition include a resonance form where the oxygen is adjacent to the carbocation, while the cyclohexadienyl intermediates from a meta addition do not.

When an oxygen (or anything with a lone pair) is adjacent to a carbocation, it can share its lone pair and stabilize the positive charge. This is only possible when the electrophile adds to the ortho or para positions, so those positions are favored with -OR as a substituent. Hence, -OR is an ortho/para director.

Note that this logic holds for any substituent with a lone pair, so -OH, -OR, -NH₂, -NR₂, -F, -Cl, -Br, and -I are all ortho/para directors.

Problem Details

MendelSet practice problem # 589 submitted by Matt on July 9, 2011.

Subject: Organic Chemistry

Subject Topic(s): Substituted Benzene EAS (EDG and EWG Effects)

Question Type: Concept (explain why this is so..)

Keyword(s): EAS mechanism, cyclohexadienyl cation

Problem # 590

-NO₂ is an EWG and a meta director. Let's draw an EAS reaction's cyclohexadienyl cation intermediates to demonstrate why this is true. I've started you off.

What's good about meta? What's bad about ortho/para?

Solution

Short answer: -NO₂ is an meta director because the cyclohexadienyl intermediates that result from meta addtition are more stable than those that result from ortho or para addition.

Long answer: Addition at both the ortho or para positions lead to a cyclohexadienyl cation that contains two adjacent positive charges. This is very unstable, and so addition at the ortho or para positions is not favored.

The cyclohexadienyl cations that result from meta addition don't have this problem.

This will be the base for any substituent that has a positive charge (or partial positive charge). So -NO₂, -C(O)R, -CF₃, -NH₃⁺, -CN, and -SO₃R are all meta directors.

Problem Details

MendelSet practice problem # 590 submitted by Matt on July 9, 2011.

Subject: Organic Chemistry

Subject Topic(s): Substituted Benzene EAS (EDG and EWG Effects)

Question Type: Concept (explain why this is so..)

Keyword(s): EAS mechanism, cyclohexadienyl cation

Problem # 595

Phenol can be prepared from benzene and hydrogen peroxide in the presence of a really strong acid. Propose a mechanism for this reaction.

Solution

The electrophile we need for this EAS reaction is HO⁺. We can generate it by protonating one of the oxygens in peroxide, which causes it to act as a leaving group.

On the left side of this image I make a note about the structure of the electrophile. Some textbooks use electrophiles with formal positive charges, such as HO⁺. Other textbooks don't use formal positive charges, and instead use partial positive charges with a leaving group, such as HO-OH₂⁺. Using HO⁺as the electrophile is analogous to an S_N1 reaction, while using HO-OH₂⁺. is analogous to an S_N2 reaction. When you draw mechanisms, you should use whichever convention your textbook uses. Both lead to the same product.

Problem Details

MendelSet practice problem # 595 submitted by Matt on July 9, 2011.

Subject: Organic Chemistry

Subject Topic(s): Electrophilic Aromatic Substitution

Question Type: Mechanism (show a mechanism using curved arrows..)

Keyword(s): EAS mechanism

Problem # 722

Show how to prepare vinyl benzene from benzene.

Solution

This is a good synthesis to know, because vinyl benzene is a good starting point for many synthesis problems you will encounter down the road.

An ethyl group can be added to benzene via Friedel-Crafts alkylation.

To add that alkene, we you will have to do some sort of elimination reaction. The easiest way to do this is via bromination. Free radical bromination (with NBS or Br₂/hν) will add a bromine to the position of the most stable radical, which is the benzylic position (due to resonance).

Then adding a strong base like potassium tert-butoxide will do an E2 reaction to form the alkene.

Problem Details

MendelSet practice problem # 722 submitted by Matt on July 24, 2011.

Subject: Organic Chemistry

Subject Topic(s): Electrophilic Aromatic Substitution

Question Type: Synthesis (show how to prepare X from Y..)

Keyword(s): free radical halogenation, EAS mechanism, Friedel-Crafts, C-C bond formation

Problem # 611

Draw in the arrows to show the electron flow and resonance forms in the nucleophilic aromatic substitution reaction below.

Note: Depending on the textbook, nucleophilic aromatic substitution is referred to as NAS, S_NAr, or addition-elimination.

Solution

SNAr is sort of like SN2, except the leaving group doesn't leave right away; a tetrahedral intermediate is formed first.

The trick with SNAr (or NAS, addition-elimination, etc.) is to draw resonance forms that stabilizes the negative charge that forms. That's why EWG increase the rate of S_NAr (they stabilize negative charges).

Problem Details

MendelSet practice problem # 611 submitted by Matt on July 10, 2011.

Subject: Organic Chemistry

Subject Topic(s): Nucleophilic Aromatic Substitution and Benzyne

Question Type: Mechanism (show a mechanism using curved arrows..)

Keyword(s): SNAr

Problem # 612

Draw a mechanism for the nucleophilic aromatic substitution (S_NAr) reaction below. Show all resonance forms of the intermediate.

Solution

For S_NAr to work you need to have electron withdrawing groups (EWG) either ortho or para to the leaving group.

This molecule has two leaving groups (chlorines), but only one chlorine has EWG ortho/para to it. So that's the carbon where the nucleophile (NH₃) will attack.

Why do EWG need to be ortho/para? Because that's the only way for the negative charge to be stabilized by resonance. Try it- if you have the NH₃ attack the other carbon with a chlorine, you will not be able to draw a resonance form that places the negative charge on one of the EWG.

Problem Details

MendelSet practice problem # 612 submitted by Matt on July 10, 2011.

Subject: Organic Chemistry

Subject Topic(s): Nucleophilic Aromatic Substitution and Benzyne

Question Type: Mechanism (show a mechanism using curved arrows..)

Keyword(s): SNAr

Problem # 615

Let's go through a benzyne reaction (also called elimination-addition).

In the reaction below, the strong base (NaNH₂) will form a benzyne intermediate, which when forms either ortho nitroaniline or meta nitroaniline.

Used curved arrows to show the formation of each intermediate and the final products.

Solution

First the ^-NH₂ acts as a base to eliminate a leaving group and form Benzyne. Then the ^-NH₂ acts as a nucleophile and attacks the benzyne, and the "leaving group" is the triple bond.

Problem Details

MendelSet practice problem # 615 submitted by Matt on July 10, 2011.

Subject: Organic Chemistry

Subject Topic(s): Nucleophilic Aromatic Substitution and Benzyne

Question Type: Mechanism (show a mechanism using curved arrows..)

Keyword(s): benzyne

Problem # 305

Rank each group of acids in order of decreasing acidity. (1 = most acidic)

Explain your reasoning. You will have to use more than one rule in your explanation (resonance, electronegativity, atomic radius, etc.).

Solution

Phenol is more acidic than cyclohexanol because the conjugate base of phenol (phenolate) has resonance while the conjugate base of cyclohexanol does not.

Thiophenol is more acidic than phenol because sulfur is larger than oxygen, and so RS^- is more stable than RO^-.

Problem Details

MendelSet practice problem # 305 submitted by Matt on June 7, 2011.

Subject: Organic Chemistry

Subject Topic(s): Acid Strength Trends and Conjugate Base Stability, Phenols (Claisen Rearrangement, Kolbe-Schmitt, Phenol EAS)

Question Type: Concept (explain why this is so..)

Keyword(s): resonance, acid strength

Problem # 581

Draw all products for the two reactions below.

The allylic alkene gives two products- the 1,2 product, and the 1,4 product.

However, the benzylic alkene only gives the one product (analogous to the 1,2 product), instead of multiple products (like the 1,4 product, 1,6 product, and 1,8 product). Why is this the case?

Solution

The allylic carbocation has two resonance forms, and so two positions where a nucleophile can attack, yielding two different products (1,2 and 1,4).

The benzylic carbocation has four resonance forms, and so in theory, four positions where a nucleophile can attack. But all but one of these resonance forms yield a product that is not aromatic, and so do not form.

Aromatic compounds are very stable; aromatic starting materials tend to only form products that are also aromatic.

Problem Details

MendelSet practice problem # 581 submitted by Matt on July 9, 2011.

Subject: Organic Chemistry

Subject Topic(s): Benzene Side Chain Reactions and the Benzylic Position

Question Type: Mechanism (show a mechanism using curved arrows..)

Keyword(s): conjugate addition, allylic position, benzylic position

Problem # 1281

Allylic and benzylic halides tend to undergo both S_N1 and S_N2 substitution reactions at a faster rate than their alkyl counterparts.

For example, both allyl chloride and benzyl chloride undergo S_N2 reaction at a faster rate than propyl chloride.

The same holds true for SN1 reactions: a 2° allyl or benzyl halide undergoes S_N1 reaction faster than a 2° alkyl halide. Explain.

Solution

There are separate explanations for SN1 and SN2.

S_N1: The S_N1 mechanism involves a carbocation intermediate, and both allylic and benzylic carbocations have resonance, which increases the stability of their carbocations, and speeds up the rate of S_N1 reaction.

S_N2: This explanation is less obvious, and is probably only mentioned in passing in your orgo textbook, if at all.

The pi systems present in allylic and benzylic halides are able to overlap with the pi orbitals of the nucleophile and the leaving group in the 5-coordinate transition state of an S_N2 reaction. This orbital overlap lowers the energy of the transition state (which stabilizes it), and so increases the rate of S_N2 reaction.

There are other possible explanations as well (Which also vary by textbook). For one, an allylic halide is less sterically hindered than an alkyl halide (less hydrogens sticking out in 3D).

Also, the carbons on the double bond of allyl and benzyl compounds are sp² hybridized, and so are more electronegative than sp³ carbons. So the sp²carbons pull alway some electron density from the alpha carbon (the carbon attached to the leaving group), making it more electrophilic, and thus increasing S_N2 reactivity.

Problem Details

MendelSet practice problem # 1281 submitted by Matt on October 1, 2011.

Subject: Organic Chemistry

Subject Topic(s): Conjugated Dienes and the Allylic Position (Kinetic vs Thermodynamic Control), Benzene Side Chain Reactions and the Benzylic Position

Question Type: Concept (explain why this is so..)

Keyword(s): E1 mechanism, SN2 mechanism, allylic position, benzylic position

Problem # 594

A chemist tried to prepare compound A from benzene via Friedel-Crafts alkylation and instead produced compound B.

Why did this happen? How could the chemist prepare compound A?

Solution

Friedel-Crafts alkylation is prone to carbocation rearrangement. In this case, alkylation produced a 1º carbocation which rearranged to a 3º carbocation, leading to compound B.

We can avoid this by instead doing Friedel-Crafts acylation. The intermediate in acylation is the acylium ion, which is stabilized by resonance and so won't rearrange.

But after the acylation reaction we have to get rid of the carbonyl (C=O) group, so we do a Wolff-Kishner reduction (N₂H₄/NaOH, heat).

Problem Details

MendelSet practice problem # 594 submitted by Matt on July 9, 2011.

Subject: Organic Chemistry

Subject Topic(s): Electrophilic Aromatic Substitution

Question Type: Concept (explain why this is so..)

Keyword(s): carbocation rearrangement, EAS mechanism, Friedel-Crafts, Wolff-Kishner

Problem # 592

Naphthalene undergoes eletrophilic substitution at C-1.

Why is this the case, even though substitution at C-2 gives more resonance forms?

Solution

Substitution at C-1 and C-2 both lead to many resonance forms. But the resonance forms that arrise from substitution at C-2 are not aromatic, while the resonance forms from substitution at C-1 are aromatic (the benzene ring is maintained).

So the C-1 resonance forms are more stable than the C-2 resonance forms, so substitution occurs at C-1 instead of C-2.

Problem Details

MendelSet practice problem # 592 submitted by Matt on July 9, 2011.

Subject: Organic Chemistry

Subject Topic(s): Substituted Benzene EAS (EDG and EWG Effects)

Question Type: Concept (explain why this is so..)

Keyword(s): EAS mechanism

Problem # 616

Let's go through another way to make benzyne.

First, let's form a Grignard reagent. Then, let's elminate to form benzyne.

Solution

Halogens get more reactive towards Grignard formation as we go down the periodic table, so Mg⁰ will form a Grignard with Br before F.

Grignards behave like negatively charged carbon atoms- very unstable. So even though fluorine is a poor leaving group, the negative carbon will cause it to eliminate to form benzyne.